Accuracy in sourcing quotes

Well, yes:

Peter Navarro, an economist who has written a number of books on China, has employed Ron Vara as a source in at least five of his works, quoting his anti-Beijing views.

OK:

Mr Navarro batted away criticism of his Ron Vara character, comparing it to director Alfred Hitchcock’s cameos in his own movies.

It was, he told the Chronicle, “refreshing that somebody finally figured out an inside joke that has been hiding in plain sight for years.”

Quite.

The Telegraph could have done better there tho’:

Ms Morris-Suzuki told the Chronicle of Higher Education, which first reported the story, that she took a dim view of quoting fictional characters and was left “wondering whether there might be other invented sources in Navarro’s work”.

She said she has not discovered any, but did find a quote in one book on China credited to Leslie LeBon, whose credentials are not listed in the book. An online search revealed that Ms LeBon is an architect – and also happens to be Ms Navarro’s wife.

Sigh.

3 comments on “Accuracy in sourcing quotes

  1. I can’t be bothered to keep up with the insanity over at The Guardian’s Comment is Free (sic) these days, but in the glory days of Bindel and Valenti they were far lazier.
    They would make a contentious fact-free statement then link to a supposed confirmatory source. A fair proportion of the time the link would go to another fact-free piece by the same writer.
    On other occasions they would try a bit harder and the link would be to another statistically-allergic activist, who sometimes linked to another and another… all with not a verifiable fact in sight.

  2. It’s not as if it’s a particularly fiendish anagram, the similarity in how it sounds is very obvious even before looking at the actual spelling

Leave a Reply

Name and email are required. Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.