This week, we learnt that one in five English farmers has received a letter from the Rural Payments Agency, demanding a total of £37 million that it overpaid in 2005 and 2006.

The agency now admits that it miscalculated 10,000 payments totalling £20 million in 2005 and a further 7,000 valued at £17 million in 2006. The overpayments in the current round range from £300 to £15,000.

Many of the farmers involved did not know they had been overpaid and the agency – quite unjustly – refuses to tell them why its former calculations were wrong.

We\’re going to claw back the money but we\’re not going to tell you how we\’ve calculated it?

Given that the decision to claw back is an admission that they get the calculations wrong, how can anyone have confidence in this set of claculations?

3 thoughts on “Eh?”

  1. Well, how about the idea that actually there was no overpayment, but that sending out 10000 letters to claim 37 Million is an elegant way of collecting extra tax…

  2. Why does the Government always overpay? Surley, if their mathematics are so bad, there should be underpayments also being discovered?

  3. As a recipient of RPA payments I can never work out how they are calculated, the information they supply is pitiful there is no way of checking if they have got it right or not. A thousand either way would be hard to detect and not worth querying. So farmers having banked overpayments will mostly be a genuine innocent oversight.
    When they overpaid me £19,000 they realised and were on the phone before I had a chance to splurge on my ill gotten wealth….

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *