Oh my, this is going to be fun

Polly\’s on the warpath about corporate taxation. In fact, The Guardian is going to have a major report on it on Monday. And from what I can see they\’ve swallowed the Richard Murphy view hook, line and sinker.

 Which means that the whole research is going to be most interesting. There will be, for example, no examination of the Guardian Media Group\’s own accounts….accounts which show a 4.99% tax rate in one recent period I seem to remember. Nor of the GMG\’s use of offshore companies to dodge (entirely legally) Stamp Duty.

But much more importantly they\’re making a basic logical error. Companies do not pay tax. Only individuals do. Companies are simply a convenient legal fiction, not real people. The real point about corporation tax is what is the incidence? What mixture of real people carry the economic burden of the tax? There\’s only three groups that can, the workers in the form of lower wages, the customers in higher prices and the shareholders in lower returns. Research shows that it is in fact 70% carried by workers in the form of lower wages and 30% by shareholders (that\’s for the US). Another study shows that every pound of corporation tax paid lowers wages by more than one pound.

So, sharpen your pencils for Monday, as I say, it\’s going to be interesting. They\’re going to be wrong in detail, that we know, but they\’re also going to be wrong in their basic construction. For they simply do not understand the concept of tax incidence.

And as Polly says:

Paying taxes makes us citizens. Living and voting together, citizenship means belonging to the community that decides how much tax to levy and how to spend it.

As businesses cannot vote, they shouldn\’t be paying tax then, should they? For they are not citizens.

7 thoughts on “Oh my, this is going to be fun”

  1. No taxation without representation!

    Though some corporations seem to be getting ample representation in the Lords…

    If citizenship, taxation and voting are so intertwined perhaps those in receipt of taxpayer’s money should not be voting.

  2. Presumably Pol would be eager to prove her citizen credentials (of here or Tuscany?) by saying how much tax she pays.

    And if paying taxes makes us citizens would that mean those who pay more in tax should have a bigger voice in how things are run?

  3. Would be so much simpler to make the UK a tax haven instead of closing down the others, with all the immense effort that would take. It would probably waste more taxes and political capital doing that than just letting them be.
    The example of Hong Kong is good – they get a third of their revenue by taxing landowners (not tenants, as they stupidly do here – another example of taxing easily avoidable things) and can thus have lower taxes on income. It doesn’t have to even imply cutting taxes – only shifting them so that the incentives are different.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *