How very excellent

There are zero confirmed cases of a man pretending to be a trans woman to commit sexual assault.

So that rapist, who transitioned, got into a women’s prison and sexually assaulted several inmates was just a fever dream then?

20 thoughts on “How very excellent”

  1. I assume to arrive at that assertion they argue (implicitly) one of the following:
    1. No man “pretends” to be a trans woman – they are just a “woman”. Therefore all assaults are by women and not men pretending
    2. Women are not capable of sexual assault, only men. This man became a woman and was therefore no longer capable of sexual assault

  2. Dennis, Bullshit Detector

    You know, if it doesn’t touch Carrie directly, it doesn’t exist.

    We’re in the middle of a pandemic that is killing tens of thousands and impacting hundreds of millions and she carries on like it’s April, 2019… Look at me! Me, me, me! I’m the one who is really suffering. Me!

    As insufferable as Richard Murphy, but not quite so stupid to be as funny as Richard Murphy.

  3. This bit is actually quite interesting:

    They aren’t really propositions to be proved true or false – they are ways of telegraphing disgust.

    Preach. “Homophobia”, “Transphobia”, at al are deliberate misnomers, designed to obfuscate and pathologise normal human reactions.

    Nobody is afraid of Sir Elton John or Keith Vaz, but they might be disgusted to hear about alleged homosexual conga lines in the allegedly marital bed or indiscriminate chemsex manlove with a roomful of anonymous bumholes.

    Few people (except maybe the poor wives) are afraid of Decepticons, they’re viscerally disgusted by the sight of pudgy middle aged blokes caked in makeup and squeezed into stripper clothes.

    But for why does the disgust reaction exist? Darwin mentioned it, but I don’t think he had a theory to explain it. Evo psych suggests it’s a self-protection mechanism, avoid eating putrid meat and all that. Which doesn’t say anything particularly flattering about people whose behaviour we find disgusting.

    Far better to pretend people don’t approve of you because they’re irrationally frightened.

    Of signalling to those who fall outside normative conceptions of gender: ‘you don’t belong here’.

    But why do normative concepts of gender exist in the first place, and why should people be disgusted by those who step outside them?

    The standard academic theory seems to be something like: gender is an oppressive matrix of the global patriarchy, which itself is an abusive conspiracy that has persisted across all known human history, because men are bastards.

    If we’re being more realistic, it’s probably got something to do with the awful consequences of genderbending. “Is it good for the Jews or bad for the Jews?” asks the eternal Hebraic question. Same goes for the other tribes of Man.

    Is tolerance – itself a very modern social construct almost unheard of in history – of men who declare themselves to be women good for Stig’s clan or bad for Stig’s clan?

    Stig is simple caveman. But Stig think tribe need healthy babies, strong hunters, wise elders, and protect females. Why funny man wear lady furs and expect treat him like female, Stig not know.

  4. If I recall correctly the person you’re talking about didn’t transition, just claimed to be pre-transition and the prison authorities caved in when threatened with legal action. The people back in his home town who know him say that he’s not trans at all, just a drag artist on the local club circuit.

  5. “1. No man “pretends” to be a trans woman – they are just a “woman”. Therefore all assaults are by women and not men pretending”
    It’s a lot like the plot of The Mikado.

  6. “Public bathrooms are temples of ritual vulnerability. Whether we want to or not, we hear, smell, spectate strangers weeping openly, shooting up, emptying their bowels, having sex with other strangers.”

    Whether you want to or not, capisce?

    Seriously, what’s in these people’s minds that makes them think it’s perfectly ok to have sex & drugs in a public toilet?

  7. There’s the mutilation of the language that irritates me. Once they declared that the opposite of trans was cis, then they’ve declared that the trans they are using means “beyond, past, other side of”, so a “trans-X” is something the other side of X, beyond X, trans-Carpathian, trans-humanism, so a transwoman is somebody who is beyond woman, has left “woman” behind, is *no* *longer* “woman”.

  8. we hear, smell, spectate strangers weeping openly, shooting up, emptying their bowels, having sex with other strangers.

    Do we? Fat mental bloke must visit different public bogs to me. But then he clearly inhabits a different world.

  9. A local woman my wife knew was raped by a trans man – he was awaiting the op to change to a woman.
    That was about 3 or 4 years ago. No idea if it ever went to trial.

  10. “Whether we want to or not, we hear, smell, spectate strangers weeping openly, shooting up, emptying their bowels, having sex with other strangers”

    Other than emptying their bowels (which is, after all, what the place is for), I have never seen or heard, never mind smelt, anyone doing any of the others in a public loo.

    Do I just not get out enough?

  11. “There are zero confirmed cases of a man pretending to be a trans woman to commit sexual assault”

    So any trans women who have raped were pretending for some other reason? The rape was just incidental.

  12. She then started her rap career by working with the producer A$AP Yams, who died in 2015, after sending him on a message on Twitter

    Yams killed himself because she sent him a twit on twatter? Who twited Chynna?

    Another sleb I’ve never heard of

  13. Oddly enough just finished reading the wolf in the whale, blended Inuit and Norse mythology based on a supposed meeting of the 2 centuries ago.
    One character was a woman raised as a man, I almost didn’t bother at that point but it was done very sensibly. Didn’t turn into a gender studies screed and didn’t shy away from the violent nature of a group in a harsh climate subsistence living either. Seems the belief was ancestor spirits coming back as a child so a mans spirit could possibly be in a female baby (hence 2-spirit being used by First Nations as a LGTQ expression).
    Seems though once they started periods it was well ok the universe has decided back to the women’s duties for you, if they never started a period everyone just carried on. So very in line with what works for Stig, like taboos on women hunting etc. Again it was mentioned this was a very rare thing so could be tolerated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *