Well, depends really

JK Rowling has condemned Police Scotland for “Orwellian” guidance which allows rapists to self-identify as women, as the author became embroiled in a new row over transgender rights.

The Harry Potter writer quoted George Orwell’s dystopian classic 1984 in response to correspondence from Police Scotland, which states that rapes could be recorded as carried out by a woman if the perpetrator “identifies as female”.

What’s the definition of rape?

Under Scottish law, rape is defined as non-consensual penetration with a penis, so it could not be carried out by someone with female anatomy.

Seems pretty open and shut really. Clearly it’s ridiculous too. But then the claim is that the folks really are women, penis and all. Part of society has gone mad upon this subject.

I also think that folk are missing a trick too.

So, the question some are asking is, well, how dangerous is it allowing the ladypenis into formerly women only spaces? Difficult to tell really, isn’t it? The claims of who has done what where are difficult to sort through.

Now we’ve got a simple measure. One to legal standards as well.

So, how many rapes in Scotland committed by women? That’s the number committed by trans people, there’s our measure of danger. I have a feeling that the number’s going to be higher than the trans advocates are going to be happy with.

8 thoughts on “Well, depends really”

  1. how dangerous is it allowing the ladypenis into formerly women only spaces?

    Well, the very best of them are profoundly mentally ill and deluded, which isn’t a good start. And the ones who genuinely believe they are women seem to be in the minority these days, with the bulk being narcissistic and misogynistic perverts who shouldn’t be left alone with the cat. And I almost forgot those who only claim they identify as women either after actually raping someone.

    If we want to keep women and girls safe, we’d be advised to treat malignant perverts as such.

  2. Back in the Dark Ages of 2012 the DIagnostic and Statistical Manual relied upon by psychiatrists to sort patients into categories, divided tranniedom into those preferring to live as women and the autogynephiles who got their sexual kicks from masquerading as the opposite sex, they formed the majority.

  3. Under Scottish law, rape is defined as non-consensual penetration with a penis, so it could not be carried out by someone with female anatomy.

    False.
    The law makes no distinction in this case between non-consensual penetration with a gentleman penis or a lady penis.
    Ergo, if we are to agree that a trans person in possession of a penis is actually a woman, despite possession of said appendage, then it logically follows that said woman can commit rape.

  4. That definition of rape is sexist. I am certain that after a ‘heavy night’, there are more than a few Scotsmen who would argue ‘I was raped’ when confronted by their ‘female’ paramour from the night before (and especially so later if their mates find out).

  5. I am raped daily by the cunts in government via the inland revenue, so find it difficult to believe that possession of a penis is necessary.

  6. “Ergo, if we are to agree that a trans person in possession of a penis is actually a woman, despite possession of said appendage, then it logically follows that said woman can commit rape.”

    Indeed, logically both men and women need to have compulsory anti rape training, for example those classes male students are forced to attend. Thats the logical conclusion of all this – if transwomen are ‘real women’ and any rapes they perpetrate are chalked up to women, then both women and men are equal opportunity rapists, and all the BS we get told about how men need to check themselves for rapist tendencies etc etc is false, the same now applies to all women as well……………

  7. As with all laws dreamt up by socialists, they are so looney you can prosecute and therefore find guilty whoever you damn like, which is the whole point.

    I suspect Ms Sturgeon would not relish being raped by anyone even if the Willie was silent.

  8. There are two ratios I’d be interested in knowing:

    Rapes by born-males / total males
    Rapes by trans-women / total trans-women

    I don’t have any clue as to these numbers, hence my ask.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *