Skip to content

Money matters – we can but hope

BlackRock has warned it will vote against most shareholder green activism this year for being too extreme, in a significant u-turn by the world’s biggest money manager.

Fashions and fads, like ESG, may indeed be a method of displaying social virtue. Displaying it with other peoples’ money has its attractions.

And yet one of those grand virtues of markets and capitalism. At some point someone’s going to demand “Show me the money”. Meaning that there’s a limitation on how much of other peoples’ money is going to get pissed away on social willy waving.

Perhaps not as tight a limit as we’d desire, but there is one. Unlike systems that don’t have measurements of reality built into them.

7 thoughts on “Money matters – we can but hope”

  1. I own some shares in a Blackrock fund. I was going to ditch them because of BR’s ethics. But if they stop having any, I might buy some more.

  2. ’Unlike systems that don’t have measurements of reality built into them.’

    Are those such systems becoming increasingly rare?

  3. I’ve seen at least 2 pension companies advertising how they’re ethical and all that, and well, I think I’ll run my own SIPP.

    Apart from the thing of maybe not actually working, and that a lot of it’s going to crash, it strikes me that a lot of this stuff doesn’t have particularly high barriers to entry, so even if solar or wind get big, the margins are not going to be there.

  4. I’ve had a good go at my company pension scheme for their virtue signalling. I have zero expectation that it will have any effect though 🙁

  5. No offense to Mr. Worstall (you’re right on the threshold), but ESG is a quintessential example of the boomer mentality: making important decisions with global implications based on focus groups, polling and media optics.

    Don’t actually look for empirical evidence that any of this virtue signaling is good for your business (or your employees, customers, shareholders). And if you’re dead wrong about everything and the company has to sell, no big deal, you still got a short-term spurt of growth you can retire on with the severance you collected as you jumped ship. Fuck everyone else.

    ESG, CRT, “sustainability,” “corporate responsibility” and the rest of it will all go the way of eugenics and lobotomies. They’re the Mengele experiments of economics. Gen-X and millennials are now trying to keep it alive with the “green revolution.”

Comments are closed.

Can you help support The Blog? If you can spare a few pounds you can donate to our fundraising campaign below. All donations are greatly appreciated and go towards our server, security and software costs. 25,000 people per day read our sites and every penny goes towards our fight against for independent journalism. We don't take a wage and do what we do because we enjoy it and hope our readers enjoy it too.