As with many I think he’s more than a bit of a loon given his base beliefs. But as is also common to many I have thought – used to think – that at least he was reasonable with his loonness. If actual hard evidence slapped in hte face – say Fukushima and nuclear – then he was willing to change his mind.
And, well, no:
Elon Musk claims to be a “free speech absolutist”. But his absolutism seems to extend only to his allies. Since he bought Twitter and renamed it X, the platform has complied with 83% of requests by governments for the censorship or surveillance of accounts. When the Turkish president, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, demanded the censorship of his opponents before the last general election, the platform obliged. When Indian government officials asked it to remove a hostile BBC documentary, X did as they asked, and later deleted the accounts of many critics of the prime minister, Narendra Modi.
Last month, X blocked links to a dossier about Trump’s running mate, JD Vance, and suspended the account of the journalist who revealed it.
All of that first is a claim that Musk has been obeying the law in those varied countries. Indian law says that in India you may not do such and such therefore Musk – and X – do not do such and such in India. Imagine the shrieking if they didn’t follow local law?
The last is about doxxing. The report revealed Vance’s home address, in detail. That’s against X T&Cs. So, the post was taken down. And?
That is, Monbiot has now shown himself to be – and this is not the first time recently – just another propagandist willing to twist truth for political gain and rhetoric.
Oh Well.
But Trump’s election might also permit even greater opportunities. Musk controls key strategic and military assets, such as SpaceX satellite launchers and the Starlink internet system. As Ukraine discovered to its cost last year, he can switch them off at whim.
Erm, no. Musk didn’t turn on Stalink in hte Crimea at the behest of the Ukrainians. Because to do so would be a violation of US sanctions upon Russian re Crimea. See what I mean about party political rhetoric here?