The row centres on comments by Orla Minihane, Restore’s spokesman on the safety of women and girls, who argued that all British girls deserved protection against abuse, regardless of their families’ heritage.
At an event held by Restore’s Gateshead branch, she said: “We’ve got to protect our girls, but we have to remember that there are Indian, Asian girls, Pakistani girls, Bangladeshi girls, Somalian girls, who were born here, who are suffering this fate every day. And we have got to protect them also.”
The comments prompted a backlash from hard-line figures linked to Restore on social media, who argued that “white native girls are our priority” and “our own come first”. And they were furious when other senior figures backed Ms Minihane.
I recall, back in 2008, that at Ukip anyone who’d ever been BNP, NF or any of the rest of them was not allowed to join Ukip. On the basis that this sort would turn up if they were allowed. Restore, by trying to be that one step further out from Reform is facing exactly the same problem.
The point is not that such should not have parliamentary representation, or have a political representative. Bill Stone’s comment about cunts is true. It’s also not about whatever we might, or you or I might, think about the matter itself. Rather, there are views which are outside the Overton Window. Yes, it’s possible to shift that window, as has been done – most notably about the EU – and that takes time. It may even be a good idea to shift that window – as with the EU. But at any particular time there are ideas that are simply outside it. Electoral politics means that you cannot win if you are too wildly outside it. You lose too many toward the centre for however may you pick up at the extreme.
Please do note, this isn’t about the specific of this policy or complaint. Nor is it about whether Overton should or can be shifted. It’s that any party looking for electoral success has to cut off – as Restore is going here – the tail end of ideas. This is true of any set of ideas too.
It won’t be true if we ever move to a PR electoral system but it is true of a FPTP one.